In New South Wales, the legal system recognizes that mental health and cognitive impairments can significantly impact an individual’s involvement in criminal conduct. Section 14 of the Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW) provides a framework to divert eligible defendants away from traditional criminal proceedings and into treatment pathways. This guide explores the purpose, process, and implications of Section 14 reporting in NSW.
What is Section 14 Reporting in NSW Legal System?
Section 14 allows magistrates to dismiss criminal charges against defendants with mental health impairments or cognitive impairments, discharging them into care or treatment programs instead of the criminal justice system. Introduced in 2021, it replaced the previous Section 32 under the repealed Mental Health (Forensic Provisions) Act 1990.Key features include:
No Conviction: Successful applicants avoid a criminal record.
Treatment Focus: Defendants must comply with court-ordered treatment plans.
Flexibility: Applications can be made at any stage of proceedings, even after a guilty plea.
Eligibility Criteria
To qualify for Section 14 diversion, defendants must meet two criteria:
1. Mental Health or Cognitive Impairment
Mental Health Impairment: A clinically significant disturbance in thought, mood, perception, or memory that impairs emotional wellbeing or behavior. Examples include:
Anxiety disorders
Depression or bipolar disorder
Psychotic disorders.
Cognitive Impairment: A deficit in comprehension, reasoning, or adaptive functioning due to conditions like:
Intellectual disability
Acquired brain injury
Dementia.
Temporary substance-induced impairments are excluded.
2. Appropriateness of Diversion
The magistrate must determine that diversion is more suitable than traditional sentencing, considering factors like:
The offense’s nature and severity.
The defendant’s criminal history.
Availability of a viable treatment plan.
The Role of Section 14 Reports
A Section 14 report is a forensic assessment prepared by mental health professionals to support diversion applications. It includes:
Diagnostic Evaluation: Confirmation of the defendant’s impairment.
Causal Link: Analysis of how the impairment contributed to the alleged offense.
Treatment Plan: Detailed recommendations for therapy, medication, or support services.
Risk Assessment: Evaluation of the defendant’s likelihood to reoffend or endanger others.
Courts rely on these reports to assess eligibility and design tailored interventions. Without a robust report, applications are unlikely to succeed.
The Application Process
Step 1: Initiation
Applications can be filed by the defendant, their lawyer, the prosecution, or the magistrate.
Best practice involves early engagement with a criminal defense lawyer.
Step 2: Documentation
Forensic Report: A psychologist or psychiatrist must verify the impairment and propose a treatment plan.
Supervision Agreement: A “responsible person” (e.g., GP, psychologist, or family member) must agree to oversee compliance.
Step 3: Court Hearing
Magistrates evaluate:
The defendant’s impairment and its relevance to the offense.
The feasibility of the treatment plan.
Public safety risks.
Conditions and Compliance
Successful applicants receive a 12-month order requiring:
Condition | Details |
Treatment Adherence | Attend therapy, take prescribed medication, or participate in support programs. |
Supervision | Regular check-ins with a nominated responsible person. |
Progress Reporting | Submit updates to the court on treatment milestones. |
Breach Consequences: Non-compliance may result in case reinstatement and criminal sentencing.
Benefits of Section 14
Avoids Criminal Record: No conviction is recorded, protecting employment and travel prospects.
Tailored Support: Addresses root causes of behavior through therapy rather than punishment.
Cost-Effective: Reduces incarceration costs and court delays.
Challenges and Considerations
Resource Barriers: Access to qualified mental health professionals for reports can be limited in rural areas.
Stigma: Misconceptions about mental health may influence court perceptions.
Complex Documentation: Incomplete treatment plans or unclear impairment links often lead to rejections.
Conclusion
Section 14 reporting in the NSW legal system reflects NSW’s progressive approach to balancing justice with mental health care. By prioritizing treatment over punishment, it offers a lifeline to vulnerable individuals while safeguarding community interests. For defendants, early legal advice and comprehensive reporting are critical to successful outcomes.
References
Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act 2020 (NSW).
Legal Aid NSW. (2023). What is a section 14? https://www.legalaid.nsw.gov.au
Criminal Defence Lawyers Australia. (2022). Section 14 applications.
Astor Legal. (2025). Section 14 mental health applications. https://astorlegal.com.au
Lamont Law. (2024). Section 14 applications. https://lamontlaw.com.au
NSW Legislation. (2020). Mental Health and Cognitive Impairment Forensic Provisions Act.
Legal Aid NSW. (2023). Mental health and cognitive impairment.
Nowlan, C. (2024). Discharge under Section 14. https://chrisnowlan.com
Armstrong Legal. (2024). Diversion under Section 14.
Medicare Australia. (2024). Mental Health Care Plans. https://www.servicesaustralia.gov.au/mental-health-care-and-medicare?context=60092
Kommentare